Strategic Leadership in a Disrupted World

Supply chain and logistics is full of accepted wisdom, familiar phrases and conventional thinking. But what happens when we stop accepting them at face value? This is an ongoing series of provocative perspectives from Victor Deyglio, Founding President of the Logistics Institute, challenging some of the assumptions we’ve come to accept about our profession - and asking whether they still serve us.

Collapsible content

THE RANT: “Strategic Planning” is an oxymoron.

Much like deafening silence or seriously funny. “Strategic” is misused as an adjective describing a plan as “big” or “long term”. Strategy is NOT a bigger plan; strategic planning is not identifying actions in a longer-term horizon.

In a W5+H world, planning involves Who, What, When, Where + How. It is driven by SOPs and managed by KPIs. Plans involve step-by-step sequences of tasks integrated as processes.

As supply chain and logistics practitioners, we manage processes from source to shelf: input [supply], throughput [inventory], output [distribution], to optimize inventory [IO] and deliver value in competitive markets. This is “inside the 4 walls” thinking.

Strategy delves into Why: why do we exist as companies? Why do we choose to enter this market, but not that market? And it moves into the messy minefield of: why should we accept anything? Why shouldn’t we question everything?  Strategies focus on purpose.

As supply chain and logistics leaders, we create value [not just deliver value] for customers driving competitive advantage in markets. Value is more than just material factors; it’s about quality [exceeding expectations], innovation [uniqueness not just functionality], service
[accessibility not support], speed [flexibility not just on time] and cost [effort not just price]. This requires “outside the 4 walls” thinking, focusing on network design [ND].

Planning is about analysis and scheduling. Strategy is about synthesis and choices.

Fixated on planning as a way of life to the neglect of strategy as a way of living, one of the greatest lies we embrace is “What gets measured gets managed.”

  • First lie: neither Peter Drucker nor Edwards Deming [TQM] said that.
  • Second lie: it is misquoted. The full quote is: “What gets measured gets managed — even when it’s pointless to measure and manage it, and even if it harms the purpose of the organization to do so”.
  • First truth: it was said by Simon Caulkin summarizing what V. F. Ridgway wrote in his 1956 essay, “Dysfunctional Consequences of Performance Measurements”.
  • Dysfunctional truth: relying on quantitative performance measures distorts behaviour, motivates the wrong actions, and ultimately undermines an organization's true goals.
  • Discomforting truth: we live the lie of numerical comfort, failing to realize that not everything that matters can be measured and not everything that we measure matters.

Rigid planning supported by SOPs and KPIs creates a false sense of security and reduces dynamic strategy to a static checklist or spreadsheet exercise. Global supply chains are not just linear transaction channels. They are eco-systems driven by trans-national inter-dependencies.
They demand systems thinking, not just process management. Systems thinking is strategic.

Planning is bottom-up; strategy is top-down.

A strategy without a plan is just an aspiration...

...a plan without a strategy lacks direction. 

BEYOND THE RANT: The question that faces the strategic decision maker Is not what the organization should do tomorrow. It is, what do we have to do today to be ready for an uncertain tomorrow? Peter Drucker

The word “strategy” has military roots from the Greek: stratos refers to “army” and is based on strateo, meaning spreading out, like on a field of battle. Agein is the word for leading. Stratos + agein means leading the army on a field of battle. 

The general was called strategos, an army leader. During a battle, the strategos went to the top of a hill [top down]:

  • scanning the contours of the field and evaluating the resources on both sides [lay of the land and military strengths]. In business, this is “system pattern recognition”;
  • reflecting on opportunities and constraints imposed by the battlefield [where to go and how to get there]. In business, this is direction and distance [global markets];
  • noting the time of day [when to go and how long to get there]. In business, this is destination and duration [logistics];
  • assessing the strengths and limitations of troops and the enemy [combat readiness]. In business, this is capacity and capability analysis [resources and competencies];
  • considering how to deploy troops to achieve victory [battleplan]. In business, this is allocation and deployment.

The strategos also considered a “theory of change” [“what if” alternate thinking]: how to get from here, in a moment of uncertainty, to where we need to be, the moment of winning.

A theory of change is the battleplan. The battleplan is not an operational process plan. At best it is a contingency plan. More accurately, it is a roadmap that details how and why an action is expected to lead to outcomes and impacts. It involves mapping the pathway from initial activities to the final goals, identifying causal links, and understanding the underlying assumptions for that change. It identifies the possibility of unexpected risks.

This is not GPS mapping; the focus is on opportunities, constraints, pivoting as needed, with a strong emphasis on enabling and managing change in the face of volatility, uncertainty, complexity, ambiguity [VUCA]. 

The Greek word taktikos referred to the soldiers on the field, because they had the skills [techne τέχνη means technique] in the art of arrangement and power of order [dunamis (δύναμις) (ability, aka dynamism)]; deployment, aka move troops into position [para-taxi Παρά-ταξη (deployment = tactical formation)]; and translating the plans of the strategos into action [execution on the battlefield]. 

Tactics are the actions through which strategy is enacted but also modified, not just followed obediently. The situation on the battlefield is always fluid, never static, underscoring a key purpose of tactics to test a theory of change [battleplan] by probing the actual battleground. Tactical plans test possibilities and opportunities. There are no SOPs. 

Any action done because “that’s what we always did here” is not strategic in nature and scope; it isn’t even good tactics. That’s a cognitive bias that limits our ability to deal effectively with randomness [ultimately, a failure to understand the theory of change]. 

We all have biases that limit our ability to think, decide and act. In the face of risk – the battlefield – we suffer from our own self-generated constraints:

  • Normalcy Bias: we underestimate the likelihood of a disaster by believing things will function as they always function [Black Swan]
  • Hindsight Bias: we believe we can predict the outcome of the event even before the event occurred [Control by Past Experience]
  • Information Bias: we are convinced we need more information to make decisions, when less information is better [Analysis Paralysis]
  • Irrational Escalation Bias: we continue a course of action beyond the point where it makes sense [Sunk Effort/Funds]
  • Effort Justification Bias: we attribute value to an outcome where the effort is greater than that actual value [Pyrrhic Victory]
  • Anchoring Bias: we jump at the first piece of information to “anchor” decisions even if it is incorrect [“The report says…”]

Strategy is not big, and tactics are not small. They are different. We strategize to develop a “theory of change” about how we could use our resources to create and deliver value [victory]. Strategy is preparedness in the face of VUCA realities. A theory of change guides our choices about targeting, timing, and tactics. That is a strategic point of view.

Strategizing is contextual. It requires seeing trees and forest. The strategos on the hilltop has an overview [the pattern]. The taktikos in the valley have an intimate view. The problem is when a fog settles between hilltop and valley: both imagine they know the whole truth but fail to recognize they each have a different point of view. 

Strategizing requires both truths - knowledge of the context [big picture] along with a capacity to put that awareness into action. The first step in developing the battleplan focuses on the lay of the land on which the battle is to be fought. Off the battlefield, the “lay of the land” starts with stakeholders and their needs in the face of VUCA realities.

What’s the difference between compliance & governance?

Strategy is not a theory. It is an embodied practice that involves know-how and routines. It involves a tangible cycle of planning, training, organizing, equipping. It demands contextual competencies, including leadership, systems thinking, forward thinking, random (stochastic) decision-making. It optimizes practical variable readiness to anticipate, respond to, and recover from the uncontrollable impacts of VUCA reality. 

The critical core of strategy is strategic thinking. Strategic Thinking is having the right knowledge, skills, and behaviours to be effective, not just efficient. It’s not about the plan [SOPs], but about the ability to plan. It’s not about the resources, but about the ability to mobilize/deploy resources. It’s not about assessment [KPIs], but about the ability to analyze vulnerabilities. It’s not about communication, but about the ability to engage effectively with others. It’s not about improvements, but about the ability to learn how to improve. It’s not about compliance and obedience, but about governance.

Strategic Thinking is complex. It requires us to balance long-term goals, manage unpredictable changes, and make important choices before all the facts are clear. 

There are many moving parts. We must look at different pieces all at once. We must spot the patterns: connecting small, random clues to see a larger trend. 

There are no clear answers. Unlike problem solving, the result is never straight-forward or guaranteed. We need to project where we want to be in an unknown future. 

There is lack of control. There are many variables, many people, many options, many constraints, many reactions from people with expertise, insights, experience, opinions. 

There is the fall-back of comfort. It is easier to focus on immediate tasks instead of the big picture. We need to be flexible – able to change direction as situations emerge.

Strategic Thinking is volatile. Misconceptions abound. They need to be neutralized:

  • Misconception 1. Strategic thinking is only for senior directors: Strategic thinking is not about having authority or power; it’s about having a clear vision, understanding the context, and making informed decisions.
  • Misconception 2. Strategic thinking is the same as planning: Strategic thinking involves analyzing the current situation, identifying opportunities and threats, exploring alternatives, evaluating outcomes. Planning is the output, not the input.
  • Misconception 3. Strategic thinking is complicated and time consuming: Strategic thinking does not have to be a formal or rigid process that requires a lot of data and tools; it’s a flexible process that adapts to the needs and resources of each situation; energy and time consumption depend on the scope and complexity of the issue.
  • Misconception 4. Strategic thinking is a one-time activity: Strategic thinking is an iterative process that requires monitoring and adjustment; it continues as the situation changes, new information emerges, and feedback is received; it is a cycle of learning and improvement; it involves systems thinking.
  • Misconception 5. Strategic thinking is a solo activity: Strategic thinking is a collaborative activity that benefits from diverse perspectives and inputs; it involves active listening and feedback; it leverages collective intelligence and creativity.
  • Misconception 6. Strategic thinking is a fixed mindset: Strategic thinking is a growth mindset that embraces change, uncertainty, and ambiguity; it is not about sticking to the status quo or avoiding risks; it focuses on opportunities and challenges; it is not about being right or wrong; it’s about being open-minded.

Strategic Thinking is defiant: 

  • It challenges assumptions: What if the opposite were true? What would happen if our main belief about the contextual situation was completely wrong? Why do we do it this way? Can we separate old habits from current needs? What would we do if we started fresh today? What does ground zero look like without past baggage?
  • It tests load-bearing beliefs: What would have to be true for this strategy to work? Can we list the conditions required for success? How confident are we? Can we separate gut feelings from intelligence? What happens if a key assumption fails? Where are the weak spots that could break the entire strategy?
  • It imposes constraints [theory of change]: What if our resources are cut in half? Do we have lean, go-around options? Can we actually execute this? Do we have capacity to deliver in a timely way? How would a fierce opponent attack this strategy? Can we see through the eyes of a rival, competitor, or enemy? 

Strategic Thinking is a skillset. It is analytical, systemic, critical, creative, practical, relational, abstract:

  • Analytical: it spots patterns, assesses metrics, makes informed decisions. 
  • Systemic: is a holistic view to understand how different parts influence one another.
  • Critical: questions assumptions, evaluates objectively, finds gaps in processes. 
  • Creative: generates novel approaches to build competitive edge.
  • Practical: focuses on structure and step-by-step actions
  • Relational: is collaborative, focusing on clarity, communications, intuition
  • Abstract: is experimental [what if], focusing on future possibilities

Strategic Thinking is a toolset. It anticipates, interprets, decides, aligns, and learns

  • Anticipates: Looks ahead to spot trends, moves, future issues before they happen.
  • Interprets: Makes sense of complexity, finds patterns to understand what is happening.
  • Decides: Makes tough choices in context, even when lacking all the information.
  • Aligns: Gets different resources working together toward the same shared goals.
  • Learns: Fast-tracks lessons from successes and failures to adapt quickly to change.

END NOTE: What’s the difference is between compliance [obedience] and governance?

  • Governance provides the strategic direction and internal framework for the value and purpose of the organization.
  • Compliance ensures adherence to internal and external command and control structures, laws, regulations, and standards.
  • Governance comes from internal and external stakeholders: internally from C-level command to frontline operations; externally from interdependencies on suppliers, customers, communities.
  • Compliance comes from policies, regulations, standards.
  • Governance asks, "How do we choose to operate efficiently and ethically?"
  • Compliance asks, "What do the rules and standards require us to do?"
  • Governance is proactive, strategic, and relationship based.
  • Compliance is reactive, tactical, mandatory, and contract based [Ts&Cs].
  • Governance failures damage reputation, trust, and long-term value.
  • Compliance failures result in penalties, costs, shutdowns.

Governance Framework is cultural:

  • Purpose: mission, vision, values that explain why the organization exists [ALIGNED]
  • People: individuals involved at every level as stakeholders [ETHICAL]
  • Process: systems, policies, and procedures [TRANSPARENT]
  • Performance: evaluating how well the organization meets its goals [SUCCESS]

Compliance Framework is structural:

  • Communication: clear, consistent messages about ethical standards and expectations
  • Confirmation: internal operational controls and risk management
  • Correction: fixing root causes of violations; updating procedures in the face of change

Ultimately, it’s the shared values, behaviors, and systems that make ethical and lawful action the default choice in any organization – private sector, public sector, military.

The WWHTBT approach

If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear the result of a hundred battles. If you know yourself but not the enemy, for every victory gained you will also suffer defeat. If you know neither the enemy nor yourself, you will succumb in every battle. Sun Tzu

Strategy is organic, creative, and focused on discovering new insights and new ways to win. It seeks to influence what is not in our control, by leveraging abductive reasoning. 

We are taught inductive and deductive reasoning. Inductive moves logically from experience to conclusion. Deductive moves logically from general principles to applications. Abductive focuses on “inference to the best explanation”, i.e., what is plausible in the context of uncertainty. Ex: You turn your car key; the engine makes a clicking sound instead of starting; you guess the battery is dead.

We start with an observation and posit the most likely explanation. The goal is to form an educated guess to explain the unknown [we do not actually know if the car battery is dead]. We go from what we experience to determine how and why it happened, and subsequently project [guess] what might happen going forward [we cannot drive or go to work and so on].

Central to abductive reasoning is imagination [we surmise we cannot drive because the battery is dead]. It demands a leap into the unknown. It's exploratory, thriving on pushing the boundaries of evidence-based thought [we don’t know for sure if the battery is actually dead or whether our inability to drive is the battery’s fault]. We need to be flexible and adaptable recognizing that our conclusion is inherently provisional and iterative.

The iterative [speculative] nature of our conclusion drives our commitment to inquire further. We recognize that our understanding of the situation is complex and evolving [we need to investigate further why the car won’t start]. But provisionally, we can only rely on the details of the situation at hand [the car won’t start]. Abductive reasoning motivates.

In military terms, abductive reasoning is the core strategic thinking focus that embraces the “theory of change” as part of the battleplan. The strategos from the hilltop surmises what might possibly happen by choosing to act in such and such a way in the context of the battlefield. While we might consider this “guess work”, the real purpose is motivational: to try to influence [not control] the unknown by asking “what if”.

For example, it might be difficult but feasible to attack at night or in bad weather or up a steep incline to “influence” the outcome by catching the enemy unprepared. The abduction is what if we attack at night; the influence is surprising the enemy.

At core, strategic thinking considers multiple variables simultaneously not just sequentially. It is not “if this, then that” cause-effect thinking. It is “what if” thinking.

“What if” thinking differentiates possibility from potential. We fixate on possibility and neglect potential. The “what if” dynamic of strategic thinking works backwards from an unexplained situation to a causal hypothesis, that is, from possibility to potentiality.

Possibilities are outcomes that can happen [i.e., there is a chance greater than zero]. Potentialities are opportunities that have the capacity to happen in the future [depending on conditions]. In the end, it is the difference between quantitative analysis [statistics, KPIs] and qualitative analysis [patterns and interpretations].

A more structured approach to “what if” thinking involves a form of abductive analysis summed up as What Would Have to be True (WWHTBT) [Martin and Lafley, Playing to Win]. It asks what conditions need to exist for a choice to be successful.

Embracing the “theory of change”, the WWHTBT of the “battleplan” starts by analyzing the underlying logic of our potential decisions. It focuses on the future to design pathways [maps] for outcomes that have not yet happened [projection – if we want to do X, then we need to consider ABC]. It manages risk by identifying weak assumptions before committing resources [self analysis – if we consider doing ABC, do we have the ability].

Instead of asking a business question like "What is likely to happen?", a military planner asks, "What conditions must absolutely exist for this battleplan to succeed?" WWHTBT is a reverse-engineering framework: 

STRATEGIC ASSUMPTIONS [ENDS]

  • Alignment: guaranteed support from other nations throughout the operation
  • Willpower: threshold tolerance of casualties and economic costs
  • Agreement: neutral nations agree not to provide safe havens for the enemy

OPERATIONAL & TACTICAL CONDITIONS [WAYS]

  • Superiority: degrade enemy defenses and capabilities before operations begin
  • Surprise: prevent the enemy from anticipating the axis of advance
  • Windows: thresholds to allow air support and amphibious landing

LOGISTICS & SUSTAINABILITY [MEANS]

  • Line of communication: uninterrupted and secured supply routes
  • Inventory: high-readiness stockpiles of munitions sufficient for intense conflict
  • Retreat: evacuation architecture to reposition in 60 minutes (Golden Hour)

INTELLIGENCE & HUMAN FACTORS [READINESS]

  • Communications: tactics to withstand electronic warfare
  • Neutrality: cooperative civilians to prevent bottlenecking maneuvers

The WWHTBT Battleplan needs to articulate 3 truths:

  • Combatants: What must be true about how the enemy will react?
  • Company: What must be true about our capabilities and systems?
  • Combat: What must be true about how the battle will be fought?

Occasio in bello amplius solet iuvare quam virtus. Amplius prodest locus saepe quam virtus. Amplius iuvat virtus quam multitudo. 
Opportunity in war is usually of greater value than bravery. Terrain is often of more value than bravery. Bravery is of more value than numbers.

Publius Flavius Vegetius Renatus, Epitoma Rei Militaris, General Rules of War

Practicing strategy - a framework

PRACTICING STRATEGY turns probabilistic [what if] thinking into making choices, testing assumptions, and connecting big-picture goals to micro-actions.

We need to challenge norms and define context before jumping into tasks. We need to hold the vision in mind to guide our intuition [gut instincts]. We need to clarify in the face of volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and ambiguity, without falling into the trap of oversimplification. We need to test assumptions by actively considering opposing ideas and acknowledging what we cannot control.

Practicing strategy demands:

  • Radical Acceptance: looking at the situation exactly as it is right now
  • Shifting Focus: moving time and energy away from what we cannot change and directing it toward what we can handle
  • Releasing Burden: dropping the weight of trying to manage unpredictable events and other people's choices
  • Stopping the Fix: realizing that we cannot force others to make good decisions
  • Accepting Uncertainty: allowing the future to remain unknown instead of trying to plan every single detail
  • Focusing Response: acknowledging that we cannot stop disruptions, but we can choose how to react to them


Practicing strategy rests on our ability to ask critical questions. Our Practicing Strategy Framework is built in 5 parts:

  1. SUCCESS: What are our aspirations?
  2. PREPAREDNESS: Where will we play?
  3. ACTIONS: How will we succeed?
  4. CAPABILITY: What competencies must be in place to win?
  5. ENGAGEMENT: What systems are needed to manage the situation?

PRACTICING STRATEGY FRAMEWORK

SUCCESS: WHAT ARE OUR ASPIRATIONS?

  • ASSUMPTIONS – THE WHAT IF’s: What risks do we face?  What needs to be done? What are the constraints? Who are the stakeholders? What are our roles/responsibilities?
  • GOAL: GENERATE MOTIVATION AND WELL-BEING: Purpose [The Why]; Competence and Credibility; Fear and Power; Creativity and Achievement; Incentive and Innovation

PREPAREDNESS: WHERE WILL WE PLAY?

  • ASSUMPTIONS – THE WHAT IF’s: What is the critical infrastructure? What is our social capital? What are our communication systems? What are our contingencies? What are our leadership strengths?
  • GOAL: GENERATE FOCUS AND FORTITUDE: Competence/Skills; Confidence/Aptitude; Connection/Control; Character/Coping; Contribution/Engagement

ACTIONS: HOW WILL WE SUCCEED?

  • ASSUMPTIONS – THE WHAT IF’s: Specific: What do we need to do? Measurable: How do we monitor output? Achievable: Do capabilities support actions? Relevant: Are our outcomes significant? Timely: can we act with a sense of urgency
  • GOAL: GENERATE ADVANTAGE: Embrace Challenge; Seek Feedback; Nurture Networks; Be Persistent; Be Flexible

CAPABILITY: WHAT COMPETENCIES MUST BE IN PLACE TO WIN?

  • ASSUMPTIONS – THE WHAT IF’s: What is the source of our resourcefulness [people]? What is our collective context [social capital]? Are we mentally/physically fit [coping]? What values drive our behaviors? What is our sustainability [social/environmental] impact?
  • GOAL: CAPITALIZE ON STRENGTH: Skills; Knowledge; Aptitude; Decision Structures; Ability to Lead

ENGAGEMENT: WHAT SYSTEMS DO WE NEED TO HANDLE THE SITUATION?

  • ASSUMPTIONS – THE WHAT IF’s: What are our systemic interdependencies? What are the emergent possibilities? What is the multiplicity of causes? What’s involved in complex risk analysis? What are the tangible-intangible trade-offs?
  • GOAL: CAPACITY, ADAPTABILITY, FLEXIBILITY: Embracing Complexity, Systems Thinking, Strategic Thinking, Stochastic Decision Making, Scenario Planning

RIFF ON CONTROL: We cannot control the future. We cannot undo the past. We cannot stop time passing. We cannot command the weather. We cannot direct systemic global issues like war. We cannot prevent inconveniences like traffic jams. We cannot determine what people think. We cannot manage other people’s actions. We cannot dominate other people’s life choices. 

We can choose to control our thoughts, our words, our learning, our reactions, our attitudes, our efforts, our behaviors, our boundaries, our well-being, our time.

With difficulty, we struggle to control our anger, our anxiety, our fear, our sadness.

The difference between problems & dilemmas

CONTRETEMPS: Disruptions are not problems; they are dilemmas. Problems have clear, correct answers and can be solved with enough data, time, resources. Dilemmas involve competing priorities and trade-offs. They cannot be "solved"; they can only be managed over time. They are the “theory of change” at the heart of the battleplan, the constraints we face during our daily commute to work [gridlock].

Theory of constraints [management – E.M. Goldratt] and theory of change [battleplan] are based in systems thinking: every complex system has at least one bottleneck or limiting factor that restricts its ability to reach its goal. That factor is disruption.

In classical Greek, di-lemmas refers to “two assumptions”. Faced by two options of equal merit, we are caught on the horns of a dilemma. Simply by choosing, we are gored either by one [the one we chose] or by the other [the one we didn’t choose]. Whatever we decide, we lose something.

For example, at a fork in a road, we can either go right or go left. If we choose to go right, we never know what’s on the left. And vice versa. There is truth the Yogi Bera’s advice: when you come to a fork in the road, pick it up. You never know when you might need it.

The gap between problems and dilemmas is how we use time. We solve problems “with enough time”; we handle dilemmas “over time”. The distinction might sound subtle, but it sits between the efficient use of time and the effective use of time. One infers immediacy [with]; the other duration [over]. That raises the question: what is time?

WELL-TIMED. A standard approach to time-based decision-making under “normal circumstances” involves a structured set of guidelines that help us evaluate options and make informed choices. This is Problem Solving 101.

Following these guidelines, we can achieve clarity, objectivity, and consistency in managing the process from problem to solution. Such a decision framework involves a number of steps, not only to arrive at a workable solution but also to use time efficiently:

  1. Define the Problem: Clearly state the issue or goal that needs a decision. 
  2. Gather Information: Collect relevant facts, data, input to understand the context. 
  3. Identify Alternatives: Develop a range of possible solutions or courses of action. 
  4. Analyze Options: Evaluate risks, benefits, and consequences of each alternative. 
  5. Select Best Option: Choose the alternative that meets our objectives and criteria. 
  6. Implement and Monitor: Execute the decision, track its effectiveness, adjust. 

Problem solving, however, is bounded rationality. It is “bounded” by the information available, the deciders’ cognitive limitations, and the time available. There is a “sufficer output”: a satisfactory decision, not necessarily the best or useful one, given the circumstances. Problem solving technique is mismatched to real-world complexity.

In the real world and on the battlefield, we do not have the luxury of normalcy. It is not about solving problems. It is not about productivity, planning, and process management. It is not about efficiency. It is about the need to deal with uncertainty and complexity in the context of volatility and ambiguity. VUCA is disruptive.

Disruption forces us to balance opposing, irreconcilable choices where no single correct fix exists. Disruption demands action. We have little time to design and develop a response plan and manage its implementation. We face “time criticality”.

Time criticality involves urgency, but urgency is not synonymous with immediacy. Time criticality involves directness [brutal honesty about the given situation], but directness is not synonymous with direction [a defined course of action towards a solution]. Time criticality involves timeliness, but timeliness is not synonymous with speed.

Timeliness dictates the window of opportunity when an action must be completed. It’s the execution – arriving, happening, being done – not completed. It’s opportunistic in the face of constraint.

The context, scope, options, and potential outcomes all depend on when the decision is made. The “when” separates timeliness and time. Timeliness is the quality of doing something at the right, most useful or expected time, as needed. Timeliness is the when.

ENDNOTE:

  • Where time is a tool; timeliness is a judgment.
  • Where time moves; timeliness chooses.
  • Where time asks, “What hour is this?”, timeliness asks, “Was this done soon enough to be useful?”
  • Where time is a characteristic of a context [high noon], timeliness is a skill that depends on the “context and constraint of need”.
  • Where we cannot speed up or slow down time, we can control timeliness by being prepared.

We have time but we also make time. Time is a factor. Timeliness is an intention.

A strategic point of view: time

Your time is limited, so don't waste it living someone else's life. Don't be trapped by dogma - which is living with the results of other people's thinking. Don't let the noise of others' opinions drown out your own inner voice. And most important, have the courage to follow your heart and intuition. — Steve Jobs

WHAT IS TIME? Strategic Thinking tests load-bearing beliefs. Time is a load-bearing belief – the core conviction that our entire worldview, and even our personal identities. We need to reverse engineer our thinking about time and timeliness. We are entering the dark forest of disruption.

The simplest understanding of time is the continuous flow of events moving in one direction from past, through present, into future. It involves duration [how long], sequence [order], and measurement [when]. Our dependency on chronometers [clocks and calendars] lulls us into a sense of “absolute time”. It is calculated. The flow pattern is labeled. It aids and abets efficiency.

Once we measure something [seconds, minutes, hours] and name it [day, month], we assert absolute truth – time becomes “obvious”. What we measure we manage. What we name we call into being. By naming something, we categorize, recognize, interact with it, effectively bringing it into the shared human experience. Naming and measuring shape reality. We are the creators.

We have an overwhelming need to manage and control, so that we are not managed or controlled. How we handle time is a defensive posture. We either control time [embrace the present and set boundaries] or it controls us [demands, limits, loss]. Time is a social governance factor.

Modern physics [Einstein] suggests that the flow of time is a subjective illusion, despite its physical dimensions [duration, sequence, measurement]. One could argue that time is a construct, not an ‘absolute’. The present moment is what we say it is; we call it “now”. We allow “now” to be the rule. Let’s pause and think about that…what do we mean by “now”?

“Now” is understood in relation to past [then] and future [later]. In effect, when we use the word “now”, we automatically connote before and after. Now, aka today, is suspended between yesterday and tomorrow. This is how we structure reality.

We convince ourselves that the past is the teacher; the present is the action; the future is the motivation. But that is a psychological governance factor: memories/lessons, choices/emotions, dreams/goals. We interpret this as a straight line moving from yesterday to tomorrow, but that straight line is “in our heads”.

In addition, we even question the validity of each: the past might have been real [depending on evidence]; now might be real [depending on our consciousness]; tomorrow is not yet real [despite what we hope for]. This is how we structure life; we structure time.

Even the use of the word “now” is experientially complex:

  • it can be precise [“at the present time” as in “we are hiring now”]
  • it can be generic [“at this moment in time”, as in contextual time]
  • it can be directional [“immediately”, as in ‘do it now, not later’, i.e., speed it up].

We don’t deny duration, sequence, and measurement. But time is not a precise given, an absolute. Time is fluid; it flows in imprecise sequences. Our sense of duration changes moment by moment – our biological clocks tick but do not calculate. This is reality.

Our assumptions about time are questioned. Time is not simple; it is not complicated; but it is complex. Welcome to a strategic point of view.

Nothing in life is to be feared, it is only to be understood. Now is the time to understand more, so that we may fear less. — Marie Curie

CULTURAL TIME Beside the calculated use of time in decision-making and problem-solving, how we calculate time is culturally based. Any global strategy, whether geo-political, economic, or social, must account for cultural similarities and differences. Failing to do so is cultural domination and even exploitation.

At a recent conference in Canada, a representative from Latin America criticized the EU’s ESG policy as “neo-colonialism”: European colonizers imposing economic requirements on “foreign” nations in the name of social and environmental causes. While this was not the intent of that policy, the interpretation positioned it as exploitation by those at the receiving end of that policy. The irony does not go unnoticed.

So, with reference to something as “universal” as time, do we fall into the neo-colonial trap on the global and international trade stage? What is ‘cultural time’?

The calendar in general use today is “western”, specifically European, and quintessentially Christian. It was created in the Middle Ages at the time of Pope Gregory xiii, and is known as the Gregorian calendar. The purpose was to correct the drift of the “tropical year” [the time it takes the earth to orbit the sun] in the old Julian calendar.

The Julian calendar was a solar time-measuring system with 365 days a year split into 12 months, plus an extra leap day added every four years without exception. It was introduced in 45 BC by Julius Caesar to replace to old Roman calendar, which was lunar based.

The rationale behind the Gregorian calendar was religion, not science, and not planetary observations. It advanced the Julian calendar by 10 days to realign the spring equinox with March 21. The purpose was to calculate the date of Easter each year. Unlike Christmas, Easter is a “movable feast” aligned to seasons, not to dates. It is a “spring festival”; it is celebrated approximately around March 21, but not exactly on that date.

As a cultural phenomenon, time is subject to geo-political situations. Greece did not adopt the Gregorian calendar until 1923, and that was to align with the rest of Europe for social and economic reasons. Orthodox Churches [Russian, Greek, Ukrainians, others] still use the Julian calendar to calculate Easter, but also the Gregorian calendar to fix Christmas.

Furthermore, in Western Judaeo-Christian-Islamic cultures [the 3 religions of the book], time is associated with creation: God defines time as the created feature of the universe [7 days in Genesis]. Scriptural theology incorporates several truths about time: God created time; God is outside time; God sees everything at the same time [past, present, future in a single moment]. God created in 6 days and rested on the 7th – so God also created the week. Time as we use it originates from a belief system; time is a Western philosophical-theological construct.

In this tradition, time is also separated into two main categories: Chronos and Kairos. Chronos, the root of the word “chronology”, is sequential time counted and calculated in seconds, hours, days, weeks, months, years [God created in 7 days]. Kairos is “appointed time” – the divine moment when God breaks chronology, intervenes in human affairs and performs miracles. More significantly, Kairos refers to “the end of time”.

Chronological time is when it is best to act. Kairotic time is when it is the best opportunity to act. Chronos is calculation; Kairos is criticality. These are the culturally time-based foundations of quantitative [SOPs – KPIs] vs qualitative [opportunistic] value systems that frame multiple experiences – social, national, international, business. And we all assumed time is time.

Without indulging in philosophical debates about time, an even more fascinating insight is that “history” is also based on religious belief. History is not a scientific absolute; it is a concept that starts at creation [genesis] and ends at the last judgment [apocalypse or end of time]. There is a beginning and there is an end.

In the most usual sense, history is linear and chronological – moving from the past, through the present and into the future. That is how it is taught in school.

However, since that future is apocalyptic and all will be revealed in the end, the cultural basis of history is teleological, not chronological [whatever our teachers taught]. It is goal oriented. Time moves toward a purpose. The implications of “telos” [goals] are far reaching; they frame multiple experiences – social, national, international, business. The critical issue is “goal-directed flow”.

Goal-Directed Flow [apocalypse] means events are pulled forward by a future outcome acting by design. Goal direction reverses causation: instead of the past causing the present [linear], the future shapes the moments leading up to it [goal]. Time is a journey of achievement towards planned and determined success. Teleological dynamics are not restricted to religious contexts; they are pervasive throughout secular Western culture.

Business plans [battleplans] set organizational goals, determine strategies required to reach them, and identify resources needed for execution. It is the road map to the future driven by commitment to that future. It identifies the vision [telos/goal], mission [purpose], values [beliefs], process [goal directed flow], and resources [physical and human assets]. Planning is teleological, without being religious. That is its constraint in the face of disruption. Disruption demands strategy, not plans.

By being locked in a teleological mindset [goal directed], our ability to develop a strategic mindset becomes a challenge. Whatever our “hopes and dreams” for geo-political hegemony, success in global markets, or world peace, reality remains volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous.

Don’t worry about the world coming to an end today. It is already tomorrow in Australia. Charles Shulz [Peanuts]

CRITICAL DIFFERENCES: Is a 7-day week a necessity? No physical or astronomical law requires a week to have seven days; it is entirely a human-made social and historical construct. While the strategic point of view is not to deny the usefulness of a 7-day week, it is to question the assumption of absoluteness. To state the obvious, the global context is not uniform; the Western sense of time is not universal. Cultural time challenges our ability to function successfully in a globalized world order, and even to win on the battlefield. 

A traditional Chinese understanding of time views it as rhythm tied to nature and the cosmos rather than a linear process. Time is a vibe characterized by:

  • repeating cycles, such as seasons, the moon, the 12-year zodiac
  • cosmic harmony which is an alignment principle
  • decisions coordinated with cosmic and planetary energy [not superstition]
  • the right time to act [Confucianism]
  • the best way to act [Taoism]

Finalizing a deal involves a propitious decision, not expedient negotiations. A signed contract is a document; a shared meal is an agreement. It is time to build trust.

North American Indigenous understandings of time are relational and tied to the land, seasonal changes, and intergenerational responsibility. There are 3 dimensions to time:

  • Circular: time is recurring, spiraling forward; past, present, future are not discreet moments; they coexist and continuously inform one another
  • Dynamic: time is measured by environmental markers. These dictate the rhythm of life:
     - budding of leaves is time to plant
     - freezing waters is time to light fires
     - animal migration is time to hunt
     - foods in season is time to harvest.
  • Accountable: past and future are integral to the present. The past does not form the present; the future does not shape the present. The past [wisdom of ancestors] and the future [generations to come] are factored in decisions made in the present. 

NOTA BENE: No one ever steps in the same river twice, for it's not the same river and they are not the same person. General Heraclitus.

  • Time is not a tangible, universal, physical object.
  • Time is an emergent framework of relationships and perceptions.
  • Time bends and flows at different speeds depending on gravity and velocity.
  • Time is a label we assign to correlated changes between interacting parts.
  • There is no universal "now" that exists for everyone.
  • If you move fast, time slows down for you.

Joy makes time slip away. Fear stretches a single minute into an eternity. That’s relativity. Einstein